The screening determines whether the proposed project requires a further ESIA or not. If it is determined that the project requires an ESIA, then the scoping is carried out to determine the coverage or scope of the ESIA study.
The necessary steps in conducting an ESIA are listed below:
Step 1: Scoping and Terms of Reference a process to identify issues relevant for ESIA consideration and determine assessment methods to be used. Terms of Reference (ToR) for the ESIA study is normally prepared as an output of the scoping exercise. The ToR needs to be approved by the Ministry of Environment and the World Bank before proceeding with the ESIA.
Step 2: Baseline Data Collection
Baseline data pertaining to physical, biological, socio-economic domain cum health issues is collected to describe the status and trends of environmental and social factors against which predicted changes can be compared and evaluated.
Step 3: Identify Environmental Impacts
The ESIA exercise will identify potential impacts and assess its significance. The categories of impacts, direct, indirect or cumulative, should be indicated.
Step 4: Design Mitigation Measures
The mitigation measures should include analysis of project alternatives, compensatory measures, corrective measures and preventive measures.
Step 5: Public Consultation and Participation
The ESIA should consider public perspective and include them in the entire assessment process and should start early in the process.
-
Step 6: Develop Environmental and Social Management Plan (ESMP)
The ESMP should be developed primarily to document key environmental issues likely to arise from project implementation, prescribe mitigation measures to be integrated in the project design, design monitoring and evaluation schedules to be implemented during project construction and operation, and estimate costs required for implementing mitigation measures. This plan must be reviewed by the project management and approved before any construction activity is initiated by any sub-project.
Step 7: Prepare ESIA Report
The ESIA report should be prepared in line with the Ministry of Environment and World Bank Format.
All ESIAs/ESMP will be sent to the World Bank for review and clearance to ensure compliance with OP4.01 and any other relevant policies, procedures and guidelines. The report will also be reviewed by the Federal Ministry of Environment with all the necessary and relevant disclosures
5.3.2 Method of Impact Assessment for the ESMF
In the development of the potential impacts, environmental and social issues common to core investment activities were identified and listed in a checklist. These were presented to the individuals at the stakeholder meetings and the representatives of the organizations met during the consultations. Based on the local knowledge of the stakeholders and the available literature and field survey, the common issues were identified. Based on this, a generally simplified environmental impact matrix that links project activities with some socio-environmental components that could be used for the ESIA is presented in Annex 6.
5.4 The Potential Positive Impacts
The project is envisaged to have a range of positive environmental and social impacts. Some of these are a function of the objectives of the project, while others are a function of the way in which the project is designed to meet its objectives.
Specifically, the following are some of the benefits that could be due to the project::
-
Improved soil conservation
-
Increased farm incomes from crop output and ensuring dignity in farming practices
-
Food Security
-
Poverty Alleviation
-
Elevation of rural income and national economy
-
Improved nutrition
-
Employment creation for community members
-
Empowerment of farmers Enhanced gender opportunities
-
Improved infrastructure
-
Improved health care
-
Attainment of the Agricultural transformation agenda of the federal government
5.4.1 The Potential Negative Impacts
The potential negative impacts that could emanate from the project are presented in Tables 5.1 and 5.2 for the Agricultural activities & Agro Processing facilities and infrastructural development, in both the SCPZ and ABIR, respectively.
Table 5.1: Potential Negative Impact of the Agricultural activities & Agro Processing
Facilities in SCPZ and ABIR
|
Envisaged Activities
|
Potential Impact/Concerns
|
Agricultural activities
Crop production that involves Clearing of forest, development and operation of agricultural fields, Construction of Weirs, etc.
| -
Environmental
|
Biodiversity
-
Interference on biodiversity conservation (changes in flora and fauna)
-
Cultivation of only cassava may alter natural vegetation;
-
Fire prevention and control
|
Water Resources
-
Alterations of local natural water cycles/ hydrology
-
Weirs create a barrier across the river that can lead to water rationing for the downstream riparian communities
-
Weirs can be dangerous with regard to safety
-
Water quality issues
|
Soils
-
Cassava cultivation continuous growth deplete soil fertility and grown on slope provides little protection from the direct impact of rainfall
-
Changes in soil nutrient cycles (fertility and carbon storage capacity)
-
Soil structure and surface layer disruption due to agronomic practices
|
Air quality
-
Degradation due to vehicular movement, mobilization of equipment
-
Deterioration from burning of biomass of cleared forest and addition of carbon into atmosphere
|
Climate Change
-
Cassava is a drought-tolerant crop but long drought affects its growth especially when it occurs after planting
-
Cassava tubers rot if waterlogging stays longer than a week
|
Pesticides and Chemical Use
-
Lethal and sub-lethal impacts on other non-target biota;
-
‘Pesticide treadmill’- higher and higher doses of pesticides required to control pest populations that develop resistance and elimination of pest predators.
-
Washed out of soils, and pollute rivers and groundwater
-
Intake of toxic chemicals by plants, animals and humans
-
Improper use, contamination by high exposure due to no or poor precautionary measures leading to health impacts
|
Waste Management
-
Agricultural waste, fertiliser and chemical containers improper disposal
| |
Land take
-
Land acquisition and compensation issues
-
increased values in land prices leading to economic displacement of poor land tenants
|
Displacement Maintaining Livelihoods
-
Loss of fallow and agricultural Land
-
Loss of employment (land based wage employment and workers)
-
Elimination of smallholder farmers
-
Increasing demand for lands for farming/ settlements by fringe communities because productive lands not available;
|
Cultural Heritage
|
Social Tension,& conflict
-
Restriction and outright loss of grazing ground
-
Social exclusion of women or the vulnerable persons
|
Traffic and Transportation
-
Increase in traffic on the roads
-
Accident to people and animals
|
Public and Occupational health and safety
-
Lack of awareness creation programs on health and safety including chemical handling.
-
Unavailability and poor use of personal protective equipment and limited/ no enforcement process
-
Influx of people resulting in spread of communication diseases
|
Safety and security
-
Safety and security of community informants/ whistle blowers
-
Safety and security of project field staff
|
Cassava Processing which involves
Dealing with waste,
Treatment technologies for wastes from processing, etc
|
Cassava Processing
-
Pollution of Waters
-
Pollution of environment due to processing with high concentration of organic matter, cyanide and processing chemicals
-
Solid wastes Generation lead to foul odor, especially from the final slurry waste and leachates formed by rain
-
Visual impacts due to unsightly stagnant ponds and ditches
-
Dust emissions from milling operations
|
Table 5.2: Summary of Envisaged Activities/Impacts and Mitigation Measures SCPZ & ABIR infrastructures Development and Operations*
|
|
Envisaged Activities
|
Potential Impact/Concerns
|
Development of Gas Pipeline
Transmission Lines, Water supply system, Access Roads,, etc
All with the following common activities:
Site clearing and/or leveling, Compacting & Blasting, Use of heavy equipment and hazardous materials, Material Extraction/quarrying, Slope stability/Excavation, cutting, and filling, Hazardous materials storage and disposal, Waste management, Construction camp and crew set up, and Land use/Land take
|
Environmental
|
Biodiversity
Site clearing and/or leveling with
-
Damage to sensitive terrestrial ecosystems (changes in flora and fauna)
-
Development of bare soil which cause erosion, siltation, changes in natural water flow, and/or damage to aquatic ecosystems
-
Endangering of Species (flora and fauna
|
Water Resources and Drainage
-
Alterations in local natural water cycles/ hydrology
-
Scour and erosion below unprotected drainage out falls
-
Disruption of groundwater or drinking or irrigation water
|
Soils and Slope stability/Excavation,
cutting, and filling
-
Landslides or other forms of mass instability on slopes
-
Development of erosion or gullies
-
Crosses of major areas of deep- seated instability
-
When excavated soil is piled inappropriately cause erosion, siltation, changes in natural water flow, and damage to aquatic ecosystems
-
Destroy valuable ecosystems when fill is inappropriately placed such as on water courses and land subsidence
-
Exposure of inhabitants and crew to risk of falls and injuries in excavation pits
|
Air quality and Noise
-
Degradation due to vehicular movement, mobilization of equipment, construction activities such as earthworks,
-
Deterioration from burning of biomass from clearing and addition of carbon into atmosphere
|
Use of heavy equipment and hazardous Materials
-
-
Cause erosion due to machinery tracks, damage to roads, stream banks
-
Compact soil, change surface and groundwater flows, and adversely affect future use for agriculture
-
Contaminate ground or surface water when hydraulic oil, motor oil or other harmful mechanical fluids are spilled or dumped
-
Put workers at risk from exposure to hazardous materials
-
Spills, leaks or injuries from any type of hazardous material (e.g. bitumen, cement, paint, explosives, fuels, lubricants)
-
Improper use, contamination by high exposure, no precautionary measures leading to health impacts
-
High volume of waste/spoil
-
Spoil tipped away from designated areas and failing or being washed on the farmland
|
Waste Management
-
Construction and other types of waste generated
| | |
Land use/Land take
-
Displacement due (i) to affected persons living or engaged in livelihood activity within the right of way; or (ii) for technical or safety reasons, the infrastructure route departs from the existing alignment and affects persons living or engaged in livelihood activities with the altered right of way.
|
Construction - camp and crew
-
Damage local habitat, compact soil, and create erosion via building and occupation of construction camp
-
Contaminate surface water and spread disease via solid waste and faeces generated by camp Spread communicable diseases including malaria, tuberculosis, and HIV/AIDS via construction crew who come from outside the region
-
Introduce alcohol or other socially destructive substances via construction crew
-
Adversely affect local flora and fauna (especially game and fuel wood) via poaching and collection by construction crews
-
Generate trash due to lack of solid waste management
|
Utility Disruptions
-
Need to realign utility supply lines
-
Increase in traffic and interruption of local traffic
|
Safety and security
-
Safety and security of community informants/ whistle blowers
-
Safety and security of project field staff
-
Increased vehicular speed that could lead to significant increases in accident rates for both human and animal populations.
-
Operation of machinery endangers both operators and laborers
-
Poorly planned borrow pits and quarries pose threats, ranging from falls from quarry faces to drowning in quarry pits that have become standing water reservoirs
|
Public and Occupational health and safety
-
Road crew members from other geographic areas can spread various health problems, especially
-
HIV/AIDS and other sexually transmitted infections (STIs), to local populations
-
Accidents from operation of construction equipment
-
Accident due to disorganized site
-
Unavailability and poor use of personal protective equipment and limited/ no enforcement process
-
Explosion/leakage of gas from pipeline
|
Cultural Heritage
-
Alteration of socio-cultural values and the stability of communities adversely affected by
-
Exposure to rapid social change or tourism.
-
Graveyards and Sacred Areas
-
Excavation may reveal archaeological or other valuable cultural resources which could be physically damaged from construction activities.
|
|
Social Tension
-
Local people excluded from project activities
-
Promises made to local people during feasibility and planning phases
-
pastoralists likely to lose grazing grounds for their livestock
|
|
Maintenance
|
*The ESIA/ESMP shall provide further specific details when the exact sites and magnitude of the sub-project are known including their impacts
|