|
|
Target Values
|
Data Collection and Reporting
|
Outcome Indicators
|
Baseline
|
YR1
|
YR2
|
YR3
|
YR4
|
YR5
|
Frequency and Reports
|
Data Collection Instruments
|
Responsibility for Data Collection
|
Draft national forest policy, regulatory framework or promotion programs that includes plantations and biodiversity established and disseminated.
|
No national forest policy, regulatory framework or promotion program that includes plantations and biodiversity
|
|
25%
Draft document(s) completed
|
50%
Draft document(s) disseminated and debated
|
100%
Final document(s) completed
|
|
Measured yearly as part of annual comprehensive project implementation monitoring report.
|
Draft policy document/Decrees
Draft policy document
Official reports on policy matters
|
Project Implementation Unit (administrative unit)
|
At least 3 provinces establish or elaborate draft forest policies regulatory framework or promotion programs with consideration to biodiversity.
|
No provincial forest and biodiversity policy,regulatory framework or promotion programs
|
|
|
1 draft document(s) completed
|
3 draft documemt(s) completed
|
3 draft document(s) discussed and final versions elaborated
|
Same
|
Draft policy document/Decrees or Provincial recognition
Draft policy document
Official reports on policy matters
|
SAGPyA/(administrative unit)
|
Planning tools identify priority biodiversity areas in the production landscape and are recognized in the forestry promotion systems at national and provincial levels.
|
Biodiversity and production visions developed for Patagonia and Mesopotamia not integrated into forestry planning and management
|
|
Small-scale maps completed in 3 provinces.
|
Small-scale maps completed for 7 provinces and the federal government
|
Maps validated through workshops in 7 provinces and government
|
Maps adopted and in use, and results incorporated into draft resolutions, in 7 provinces and federal government
|
Same
|
GIS systems
Reports on national and provincial strengthening components
Maps Developed at small scale for all provinces in project
National monitoring system
Annual project evaluation on management at national and provincial levels
Drafted resolutions or regulations with new biodiversity requirements.
|
SAGPyA/(administrative unit)
|
Increase in locales identified for private and public protected areas for biodiversity conservation as result of improved dialogue and governance in the forestry sector.
|
No new areas identified in the production landscape
0 hectares
Total new areas identified for protection.
|
|
|
2 new areas identified
|
5 new areas identified
|
7 new areas identified
|
Same
|
Reports and pertinent decrees or recognition
Annual project implementation reports
|
Administrative unit
APN/FVSA/Forestry companies
|
Increase in number of hectares under improved management for biodiversity (large producers) as determined by technology transfer program criteria.
|
0 hectares under improved management
|
|
|
10,000 ha total
|
25,000 ha total
|
50,000 ha total
|
Same
|
Reports and GIS maps
Monitoring reports of pilot projects and technology transfer trials
|
SAGPyA/(administrative unit)
|
Increase in number of hectares under improved or alternative management for biodiversity (small and medium <1000 ha)
|
0 ha
|
|
|
5,000 ha total
|
10,000
ha total
|
20,000 ha total
|
Same
|
Reports and GIS maps
Monitoring reports of pilot projects and technology transfer trials
|
SAGPyA/(administrative unit)
|
Monitoring shows improvement in ecosystem biodiversity (for habitats of globally-important biodiversity indicator species) and presence of indicator spp in production landscape in intervention areas
|
Increased connectivity of ecosystems and presence of indicator spp.
|
|
Indicator spp. identified for monitoring
|
Increased connectivity within 3 critical ecosystems through corridors established or restored. Indicator spp. monitored in 1 ecosystem.
|
Indicator spp. monitored in 3 ecosystems.
|
Increased connectivity within 5 critical ecosystems through corridors established or restored. Indicator spp. monitored in total 5 ecosystems
|
|
Reports and GIS maps
Field visits
reports
|
SAGPyA/(administrative unit). Steering Committee.
|
Results Indicators for Each Component
|
Baseline
|
YR1
|
YR2
|
YR3
|
YR4
|
YR5
|
Frequency and Reports
|
Data Collection Instruments
|
Responsibility for Data Collection
|
Component One :
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Percentage of designated Direccion Forestal officials trained in biodiversity and plantations
|
no official trained
|
25%
|
100%
|
|
|
|
Same
|
Annual training reports
|
Administrative Unit
|
Percentage of designated pertinent provincial officials trained in biodiversity and plantations
|
No officials trained
|
25%
|
100%
|
|
|
|
Same
|
Annual training reports
|
Administrative Unit
|
Designated national authorities completed and applying EIA training
|
1 official trained
|
33%
|
66%
|
100%
|
|
|
Same
|
Annual training reports
|
Administrative Unit
|
Designated provincial authorities completed and applying EIA training
|
No officials trained
|
25%
|
50%
|
75%
|
100%
|
|
Same
|
Annual training reports
|
Administrative Unit
|
Participating extensionists trained and applying knowledge on best practices in field
|
No extensionists trained
|
50%
|
100%
|
|
|
|
Same
|
Annual training reports
|
Administrative Unit
|
Provincial forestry offices equipped for biodiversity databases and sustainable management.
|
0
|
2
|
4
|
7
|
|
|
Same
|
Project management and procurement information systems
Annual training reports
|
Administrative Unit
|
Biodiversity planning and monitoring tools developed
|
0
|
|
2
|
4
|
7
|
|
Same
|
GIS products, maps, and workshop reports
|
Contractors/ Administrative Unit
|
Draft policies, regulations and/or promotion programs developed and consulted with stakeholders
|
0
|
2
|
4
|
7
|
|
|
Same
|
Draft policies
Official policy documents
|
SAGPyA/Provinces/ Administrative Unit
|
5 of 7 provincial environmental agencies employ stronger biodiversity criteria in Environmental Impact Assessments
|
0
|
|
1
|
3
|
5
|
|
Same
|
Draft regulations
EIA reporting
Official documents
|
SAGPyA/Provinces/ Administrative Unit
|
Draft federal legislation and associated regulatory framework incorporating appropriate biodiversity concerns developed and presented for promulgation and adoption
|
New legislation not drafted
|
|
33%
(Draft legislation and regulations completed)
|
66%
(Draft legislation and regulations consulted)
|
100%
(Recommended legislation and regulations presented for adoption)
|
|
Same
|
Proposed legislation and regulations
Draft legal analysis and proposals
Proceeding from consultation
Draft laws and regulations
|
SAGPyA/ Administrative Unit
|
Component Two :
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Roundtables established in all Provinces in project area incorporating biodiversity into policy discussions.
|
0 roundtables
|
|
2 roundtables incorporate biodiversity considerations in policy discussions
|
4 roundtables incorporate biodiversity considerations in policy discussions
|
6 roundtables incorporate biodiversity considerations in policy discussions
|
7 roundtables incorporate biodiversity considerations in policy discussions
|
Same
|
Policy statements, official participation and recognition documents
Periodic roundtable meeting minutes.
|
SAGPyA
|
Economic analyses developed for plantations and biodiversity in all 7 provinces involved in project
|
0 analyses
|
|
2 provinces have completed economic analyses
|
4 provinces have completed economic analyses
|
6 provinces have completed economic analyses
|
7 provinces have completed economic analyses
|
Same
|
Final consultancy reports
|
Administrative Unit
|
Seed bank for (natives) networks established in Misiones, Delta and Patagonia
|
No native seedbank networks established.
|
|
1 seed bank network established
|
2 seed banks network established
|
3 seed banks network established
|
.
|
|
Seedbank documents
|
INTA/SAGPyA/Provincial Govs/ Administrative Unit
|
Toolkits developed and disseminated for
grassland, forest and wetland ecosytems (5)
|
0 toolkits
|
|
1 toolkit developed and disseminated to at least 500 producers
|
2 toolkits developed and disseminated to at least 1000 producers
|
5 toolkits developed and disseminated to a cumulative total of 3500 producers
|
|
Same
|
Development documents
Final standards publication
|
INTA/SAGPyA/ Administrative Unit
|
Pilot projects for dissemination of best practices for biodiversity completed for 7 provinces.
|
0 projects
|
1 pilot project under implementation
|
4 pilot projects under implementation
|
7 pilot projects under implementation
|
|
7 pilot projects completed
|
Same
|
Quarterly progress reports
Annual monitoring reports
Final evaluation
|
INTA/ Administrative Unit
|
Subregional international conference held in Argentina on Plantations and Biodiversity for global dissemination of lessons
|
No conference
|
|
|
1 International workshop held and results published
|
|
|
Same
|
Proceedings publication
|
Administrative Unit /World Forestry Congress organization
|
Extension programs incorporating biodiversity into forestry technical assistance developed and implemented in 7 provinces
|
0
|
Standards developed in 3 provinces
|
Standards developed in 7 provinces;
Implementation begins in 3 provinces
|
Extension programs under implementation in 7 provinces
|
|
|
Same
|
Program design report
Materials prepared
|
INTA/ Administrative Unit
|
Improve knowledge base for improvement of ecosystem conditions and reduction of threats to species of global importance through special treatments via pilot initiatives
|
No piloting of innovative treatments/approaches to biodiversity conservation in the productive landscape
|
|
2 pilots initiated in production landscape to improve ecosystem conditions and/or reduced threats through special treatments
|
4 pilots initiated in production landscape to improve ecosystem conditions and/or reduced threats through special treatments
|
5 pilots initiated in production landscape to improve ecosystem conditions and/or reduced threats through special treatments
|
5 pilots completed in production landscape to improve ecosystem conditions and/or reduced threats through special treatments
|
Same
|
Remote sensing
Field surveys
Semi-annual monitoring reports
Reports from individual pilots
Final project report
|
INTA/Universities/ Administrative Unit
|
Complete draft program curriculum for certificate in biodiversity and plantations. developed and adopted in at least 1 regional school in each of Mesopotamia and Patagonia
|
No curricula
|
|
Program curriculum draft developed and presented
|
Draft curriculum in use by 1 school
|
Draft curriculum in use by 2 schools
|
|
Same
|
Program design reports
Materials prepared
|
INTA/ Administrative Unit
|
No. of nurseries offering native tree seedlings increases by 100%
|
18 nurseries offering native tree seedlings in project area
|
|
At least 18 new nurseries interested in providing native spp. are identified
|
6 new nurseries are providing native spp.
|
12 new nurseries are providing native spp.
|
18 new nurseries are providing native spp.
|
Same
|
Field reports
|
SAGPyA, provincial forestry agencies
|
Component Three:
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Technical assistance for small and medium producers in agroforestry (Misiones) or best management practices (Patagonia and Mesopotamia) benefits 20,000 ha
|
No technical asst. to small- and medium producers
|
|
5,000 ha have benefited from technical assistance
|
10,000 ha have benefited from technical assistance
|
15,000 ha have benefited from technical assistance
|
20,000 ha have benefited from technical assistance
|
Same
|
Semi-annual reports from implementing organizations/agencies/provinces
Administrative Unit ecoregional specialist report
Annual Administrative Unit reports
Maps/GIS databases
|
Implementing agents/ Administrative Unit
SAGPyA
|
Environmental education increases awareness of plantations and on biodiversity in sampled subproject areas by 50% over baseline.
|
Baseline awareness levels to be taken at outset of program
|
|
10% increase over baseline
|
|
50% increase over baseline
|
|
Same
|
Annual surveys on awareness levels in target areas
|
Implementing agents/ Administrative Unit
|
50,000 ha of large plantations (>1,000 ha) are incorporating biodiversity –responsible practices and planning within ecoregions of global importance through project
|
0 target interventions have been carried out with large-scale producers through project
|
5,000 ha are incorporating biodiversity-responsible practices
|
20,000 ha are incorporating biodiversity-responsible practices
|
30,000 ha are incorporating biodiversity-responsible practices
|
40,000 ha are incorporating biodiversity-responsible practices
|
50,000 ha are incorporating biodiversity-responsible practices
|
Same
|
Field surveys
Industry and official reporting
|
Implementing agents/ Administrative Unit
|
Baseline studies prepared and dialogue advanced for establishment 7 of private and public protected areas within targeted eco-regions in the plantation forestry landscape.
|
Productive landscape not evaluated for new protected areas.
|
|
Baseline studies completed for 1 new protected areas
|
Baseline studies completed for 3 new protected areas
|
Public discussions completed for 5new protected areas
|
Public discussions completed for 7 ha of new protected areas
|
Same.
|
Baseline studies, workshop reports, negotiation documents if pertinent.
|
Administrative unit
|
5 Corridors restored or established in critical ecosystems or sensitive areas in the production landscape
|
0 Corridors restored or established in critical ecosystems or sensitive areas in the production landscape
|
|
1 Corridors restored or established
|
3 Corridors restored or established
|
4 Corridors restored or established
|
5 Corridors restored or established in an ecosystem in the production landscape
|
|
Remote sensing
Field surveys
Semi-annual monitoring reports
Reports from individual pilots
|
Administrative unit
|
Component Four:
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
SAGPyACoordination Team is organized formally and successfully managing project
|
Existing coordination team in SAGPyA lacks mandate to execute project
|
Team fully staffed and implementing project satisfactorily
|
Team fully staffed and implementing project satisfactorily
|
Team fully staffed and implementing project satisfactorily
|
Team fully staffed and implementing project satisfactorily
|
Team fully staffed and implementing project satisfactorily
|
Same.
|
World Bank supervision missions, reports, audits, etc.
|
Admin unit/SAGPyA
|
Monitoring programs in place and providing date to relevant national programs
|
No monitoring programs in place.
|
25%
|
50%
|
100%
|
|
|
Same
|
Annual progress reports
|
Admin unit/SAGPyA
|
Yüklə 2.67 Mb.