Analogy: slave auction + Lebron James’ Free Agency “Decision” Slave Auction, 1850

The sale's magnitude was the result of the break-up of an old family estate that included two plantations. The majority of the slaves had never been sold before. Most had spent their entire lives on one of the two plantations included in the sale. The rules of the auction stipulated that the slaves would be sold as "families" - defined as a husband and wife and any offspring. However, there was no guarantee that this rule would be adhered to in all cases.

The sale gained such renown that it attracted the attention of Horace Greeley, Editor of the New York Tribune, one of America's most influential newspapers at the time. Greeley was an abolitionist and staunchly opposed to slavery. He sent a reporter to cover the auction in order to reveal to his readers the barbarity inherent in one human being's ability to own and sell another.

• 
  In early July of 2010 an enormous athlete auction took place
  
• 
  “Word of the sale had spread through the” basketball, sports worlds – word spread far & wide
  
• 
  “Word of the sale had spread through the [world] for weeks, drawing potential buyers from” all across the nation.
  
• 
  city of sale hosted many visitors (New York, Chicago, Miami)
  
• 
  excursions to “to inspect, evaluate and determine an appropriate bid for the human merchandise on display”
  
• 
  “break up of family estate” = team
  
• 
  “The sale gained such renown that it attracted the attention of” all the major news outlets – dominated the news cycles
  
• 
  This analogy is made “in order to reveal to [its] readers the barbarity inherent in one human being's ability to own and sell another.”
  

"The slaves remained at the race-course, some of them for more than a week and all of them for four days before the sale. They were brought in thus early that buyers who desired to inspect them might enjoy that privilege, although none of them were sold at private sale. For these preliminary days their shed was constantly visited by speculators. The negroes were examined with as little consideration as if they had been brutes indeed; the buyers pulling their mouths open to see their teeth, pinching their limbs to find how muscular they were, walking them up and down to detect any signs of lameness, making them stoop and bend in different ways that they might be certain there was no concealed rupture or wound; and in addition to all this treatment, asking them scores of questions relative to their qualifications and accomplishments.

All these humiliations were submitted to without a murmur and in some instances with good-natured cheerfulness - where the slave liked the appearance of the proposed buyer, and fancied that he might prove a kind 'mas'r.'

• 
  “constantly visited by speculators”
  
• 
  “examined with as little consideration as if they had been brutes indeed”
  
• 
  pass the physical: “the buyers pulling their mouths open to see their teeth, pinching their limbs to find how muscular they were, walking them up and down to detect any signs of lameness, making them stoop and bend in different ways that they might be certain there was no concealed rupture or wound; and in addition to all this treatment, asking them scores of questions relative to their qualifications and accomplishments”
  
• 
  no objections to the spectacle: “without a murmur”
  
• 
  to the contrary, ESPN et al ran with it: “and in some instances with good-natured cheerfulness”
  
• 
  good owner = “he might prove a kind ‘mas’r’”
  

'Elisha,' chattel No. 5 in the catalogue [chattel = moveable personal property other than land or buildings - slaves], had taken a fancy to a benevolent looking middle-aged gentleman, who was inspecting the stock, and thus used his powers of persuasion to induce the benevolent man to purchase him, with his wife, boy and girl, Molly, Israel and Sevanda, chattels Nos. 6, 7 and 8. The earnestness with which the poor fellow pressed his suit, knowing, as he did, that perhaps the happiness of his whole life depended on his success, was interesting, and the arguments he used were most pathetic. He made no appeal to the feelings of the buyer; he rested no hope on his charity and kindness, but only strove to show how well worth his dollars were the bone and blood he was entreating him to buy.

• 
  Agent = slave owner: player merely as a piece of meat, worth $$$ -- “ to show how well worth his dollars”
  

Molly advances, with her hands crossed on her bosom, and makes a quick short curtsy, and stands mute, looking appealingly in the benevolent man's face. But Elisha talks all the faster.

'Show mas'r yer arm Molly - good arm dat mas'r - she do a heap of work mo' with dat arm yet. Let good mas'r see yer teeth Molly - see dat mas'r, teeth all reg'lar, all good - she'm young gal yet. Come out yer Israel, walk aroun' an' let the gen'lm'n see how spry you be.'

Then, pointing to the three-year-old girl who stood with her chubby hand to her mouth, holding on to her mother's dress, and uncertain what to make of the strange scene.

'Little Vardy's on'y a chile yet; make prime gal by-and-by. Better buy us mas'r, we'm fus' rate bargain" - and so on. But the benevolent gentleman found where he could drive a closer bargain, and so bought somebody else..."

• 
  better bargains found – in New York, Texas, and ….
  

"The buyers, who were present to the number of about two hundred, clustered around the platform; while the Negroes, who were not likely to be immediately wanted, gathered into sad groups in the background to watch the progress of the selling in which they were so sorrowfully interested. The wind howled outside, and through the open side of the building the driving rain came pouring in; the bar down stairs ceased for a short time its brisk trade; the buyers lit fresh cigars, got ready their catalogues and pencils, and the first lot of human chattels are led upon the stand, not by a white man, but by a sleek mulatto, himself a slave, and who seems to regard the selling of his brethren, in which he so glibly assists, as a capital joke. It had been announced that the Negroes would be sold in "families," that is to say; a man would not be parted from his wife, or a mother from a very young child. There is perhaps as much policy as humanity in this arrangement, for thereby many aged and unserviceable people are disposed of, who otherwise would not find a ready sale...

...The expression on the faces of all who stepped on the block was always the same, and told of more anguish than it is in the power of words to express. Blighted homes, crushed hopes and broken hearts was (sic) the sad story to be read in all the anxious faces. Some of them regarded the sale with perfect indifference, never making a motion save to turn from one side to the other at the word of the dapper Mr. Bryan, that all the crowd might have a fair view of their proportions, and then, when the sale was accomplished, stepping down from the block without caring to cast even a look at the buyer, who now held all their happiness in his hands. Others, again, strained their eyes with eager glances from one buyer to another as the bidding went on, trying with earnest attention to follow the rapid voice of the auctioneer. Sometimes, two persons only would be bidding for the same chattel, all the others having resigned the contest, and then the poor creature on the block, conceiving an instantaneous preference for one of the buyers over the other, would regard the rivalry with the intensest (sic) interest, the expression of his face changing with every bid, settling into a half smile of joy if the favorite buyer persevered unto the end and secured the property, and settling down into a look of hopeless despair if the other won the victory...

The auctioneer brought up Joshua's Molly and family. He announced that Molly insisted that she was lame in her left foot, and perversely would walk lame, although, for his part, he did not believe a word of it. He had caused her to be examined by an eminent physician in Savannah, which medical light had declared that Joshua's Molly was not lame, but was only shamming. However, the gentlemen must judge for themselves and bid accordingly. So Molly was put through her paces, and compelled to trot up and down along the stage, to go up and down the steps, and to exercise her feet in various ways, but always with the same result, the left foot would be lame. She was finally sold for $695. (equivalent to approximately $15,300 in today's dollars)

Whether she really was lame or not, no one knows but herself, but it must be remembered that to a slave a lameness, or anything that decreases his market value, is a thing to be rejoiced over. A man in the prime of life, worth $1,600 (equivalent to approximately $35,200 in today's dollars) or thereabouts, can have little hope of ever being able, by any little savings of his own, to purchase his liberty. But, let him have a rupture, or lose a limb, or sustain any other injury that renders him of much less service to his owner, and reduces his value to $300 or $400, and he may hope to accumulate that sum, and eventually to purchase his liberty. Freedom without health is infinitely sweeter than health without freedom.

And so the Great Sale went on for two long days, during which time there were sold 429 men, women and children. There were 436 announced to be sold, but a few were detained on the plantations by sickness...

The total amount of the sale foots up $303,850." (equivalent to approximately $6,700,000 in today's dollars)

References:
    New York Daily Tribune, March 9, 1859 reprinted in Hart, Albert B., American History Told by Contemporaries v. 4 (1928).

< http://www.eyewitnesstohistory.com/slaveauction.htm >

1^st trade in New Amsterdam (New York)
New Jersey-based NBA agent Leon Rose

• 
  LEBRON JAMES
  
• 
  ALLEN IVERSON
  
• 
  RICHARD HAMILTON
  
• 
  ANDREA BARGNANI
  

• 
  represents more than 350 athletes, including
  
• 
  Colts QB PEYTON MANNING,
  
• 
  Chargers RB LADAINIAN TOMLINSON,
  
• 
  Yankees SS DEREK JETER,
  
• 
  Phillies 1B RYAN HOWARD
  
• 
  Penguins C SIDNEY CROSBY
  

“represents”

NBC sports: < http://probasketballtalk.nbcsports.com/2010/07/like-it-or-not-lebron-james-decision-is-all-part-of-the-plan-and-its-working.php >

By Casey Gane-McCalla July 12, 2010 2:38 pm

After LeBron James received massive media attention for his free agency and subsequent choosing of the Miami Heat, some prominent Black leaders have made the comparison of James to a slave. Louis Farrakhan said that the NBA was a plantation and James was a sharecropper, calling NBA players “high paid slaves” and Jesse Jackson said that Cavs owner Dan Gilbert sees LebRon as a “runaway slave” after Gilbert’s harsh open letter regarding LeBron.

Comparing LeBron James to a slave is an insult to the millions of people who had to endure the forced labor, beatings, rape and humiliation of slavery.

LeBron James is far from a slave. He is no ones property, he makes money (a lot) he owns property, if he wanted to quit he could, no one can beat him (except the Cetltics). LeBron James was not forced to play basketball, he chose to do it himself. If LeBron James is a slave, you could sign me up too.

Jesse Jackson may have misinterpreted Dan Gilbert’s letter. I took Gilbert’s letter as being representative of the Cleveland community’s anger at the perceived betrayal by James. LeBron was a hometown hero in Cleveland, a city that doesn’t have many stars or attractions, a city that has been drastically hurt by the recession and unemployment where James was one of the few things that brought money and excitement to the city. While it is James’ right to play for whomever he plays for, I can understand why the fans of Cleveland are angry at him. It was this anger that Gilbert reflected in his letter, not anger of an owner mad at his runaway slave.

Basketball players are people lucky enough, hard working enough and talented enough to make a lot of money doing something most people do for fun. No basketball player is forced to sign a contract or to play basketball. While there may be economic inequalities in the NBA, calling a basketball player a slave is ridiculous. Two of the ten richest African Americans, Magic Johnson and Michael Jordan, both made their fortunes playing basketball. Many other African Americans have made millions playing basketball in the NBA and have started their own businesses and got into new careers due to playing basketball.

• 
  Too many “Hitlers” or “slavery” weakens the term, diminishes the horror & suffering or the reality